The Fourth of July is of course one of the most important national holidays in the United States. It commemorates the adoption of the Declaration of Independence in 1776. And it celebrates the birth of a nation founded on the ideals of liberty, justice, and self-government. It allows for a gentle but heartfelt acknowledgement that Americans are glad to be Americans living in that land. Yes, that is rather cheesy – but it seems true.
4th of July for Orthodox Jews: Celebrations and Traditions
The food-centred celebration does indeed suggest a typical American foodfest. But it is really deeper than that. Families honestly do get together – which – for half of them – is probably not too bad an experience. For many Americans, the holiday is marked by fireworks, parades, friends-shared-takeaway meals and patriotic ceremonies (like getting completely drunk).
Now obviously, while the Fourth of July is not a Jewish holiday, many even-Orthodox Jews living in the United States find meaningful connections between the values of American independence and the broadest teachings of Judaism. Most orthodox Jews would absolutely not make a family celebration around a sumptuous meal on the day. It’s because it would be seen to be celebrating a non-Jewish holiday as if it were parallel to the Sabbath or a festival.
However, since many Americans have barbecues and bonfires, probably many would feel that (strictly kosher) beef burgers, hot dogs and BBQ fare would do little harm as outdoor parties like this are not made on our festivals or the Sabbath. Also, as there is no religious aspect to all this. To deny the kids something they feel is ‘normal’ would be unwise. However, in capital letters, the most successful course is to give the children enormous pride and enjoyment within their orthodox life. Then we can acknowledge July 4th as an important secular, non-Jewish day which explains why the orthodox Jew can still exist in the USA.
4th of July for Orthodox Jews: America’s Unique History
This is almost unparalleled in our history. We had perhaps 2000 years in Spain and the rest of Europe but they were marked by almost constant persecution. America is the only, only country that has not, as a national policy, tortured, murdered, expelled and converted Jews. This is of course because there never has been a clear, white Christian majority to create a ‘them’ and ‘us’.
The need to persecute was tragically satisfied by the black population. This seems slightly ungrateful as everyone acknowledges that it was the black population who created the white’s wealth and dominance. What would the white fat cats have done without black slavery? As to Jews, had the USA been strongly Catholic then things may have been very different.
The Irony of Freedom and Slavery in American History
One of the central themes of the Fourth of July is almost ironically the importance of freedom. The American Revolution was fought because the colonies sought freedom from oppressive rule and the ability to govern themselves. But they had no mirrors.
This is shown by the sordid fact that the United States declared its independence from Great Britain on July 4, 1776. They then cannibalistically used their oppressive torture and abuse of the black man, to become rich. They fed off their flesh. The formal abolition of slavery throughout the United States was achieved with the ratification of the 13th Amendment to the Constitution only on December 6, 1865. Interestingly, their formal oppressors actually had done this more than 3 decades earlier on August 28, 1833.
Racial History, Current Events, and Jewish Loyalty
Thus racialism in the USA has a bloodstained history – but it is not usually aimed at the Jews. The present Iran war has interestingly created a huge ‘interest’ however in Jews in the USA and their loyalty. The use by Israel of the USA to fight its war is seen as a typically-clever Jewish plot. The truth is irrelevant. People will shriek on both sides but at the end of the day – suddenly – being Jewish is a factor and attracts attention and expectations.
This is seen clearly by the large number of Jews – some 30% – who openly profess anti-Zionistic and strongly pro-Palestinian sentiments. Another 30% seem to favor a two-state solution and restriction of the territory of Israel. Perhaps, they all know instinctively that its enslavement to modern mores. And birth-control will make secular Israel disappear within two generations. Thus, leaving huge areas for the Palestinian. Now these Jews are of course the younger ones who ironically will themselves mainly have no children and become part of the one in four who will commit self-extermination in the next 35 years. And do not blame Wokism. That is too easy. It is over for the secular white population globally. Irreversible.
Jewish History of Persecution and the American Exception
Yes, the Jewish people have a long history centred on being the victim. And yes, the USA – until today at least – represents the only society which has not persecuted Jews. The Jews know that such tolerance is usually short-lived and precious and should never be taken for granted. We are usually granted just a few generations – enough to educate our children properly in Judaism – before being partially wiped out and expelled. Sorry, I am not whining, history is emphatic about this.
4th of July For Orthodox Jews: The Future of Jews in America
As to the future, it seems utterly insane even to suggest that the USA will expel all the Jews or gas us all. But note that the Jews ‘ran’ Spain and Germany, like the Jewish fat cats run the USA today. In 30 years’ time all the wealthy, influential childless Jews will be retiring – leaving not even nominally Jewish kids. The secular number about 5,000,000 today, about 2,500,000 in 30 years and about 1,500,000 in 60 years. So an American holocaust will not be necessary. Mind you, there will be replacement by millions of black coated haredim.
Contrasting Concepts of Freedom: American vs Jewish Views
So, the Fourth of July represents a very limited type of freedom – from external rule. It does not suggest any moral imperative upon the individual that would stop him impinging on others. Yes, obviously, a central plank of the Independence Declaration is the sacred nature of all freedoms. But this was to be viewed through the lens of national needs – as slavery proves.
However, Orthodox Judaism teaches that freedom is more than the absence of oppression. According to Jewish tradition, true freedom comes from living a life guided by moral values and divine commandments. It is the ‘freedom’ of the individual from being a slave to his own desires. After leaving Egypt, we did not simply become free to do whatever we wanted; we received the Torah at Mount Sinai, which gave us a purpose – to exemplify a code of personal morality and ethics. In this sense, freedom carries responsibility.
The American ideals also echo this but obviously absolutely do not impinge on personal morality as the private behaviour of every American politician (practically) proves. That itself would be oppression in secular terms. We must be free – to be libertine. Yes, the American ideals expressed in the Declaration of Independence also emphasize that such liberty must be balanced with justice and the protection of human rights. Millions and millions of children live with not their biological parents, nor their replacements, nor their replacements. Most people regard children as out of date. And they live in strict accordance with the Declaration of Independence.
Gratitude for Religious Freedom in America
Another connection between the Fourth of July and Orthodox Judaism is our gratitude for this sympathetic host nation. Jewish law and tradition place a strong emphasis on recognizing and appreciating the blessings that God provides. Orthodox Jews recite many daily prayers thanking God for life, health, and the opportunity to serve Him in a non-hostile environment. We feel grateful for the freedoms and opportunities available in the United States. America has historically provided a safe environment where Jewish communities can build synagogues, establish schools, observe the Sabbath, and practice their faith without fear of persecution.
Throughout history, Jews often faced discrimination and restrictions in many countries. In some places, they were forbidden from owning land, practicing certain professions, or openly observing their religion. The United States, while not perfect, became one of the first nations to offer broad religious liberty to people of different faiths. This freedom allowed Orthodox Judaism to flourish. Today, many thriving Orthodox communities exist across the country, with yeshivas, kosher businesses, and charitable organizations contributing to American society. For this reason, many Orthodox Jews view Independence Day as an opportunity to express appreciation for the country’s commitment to religious freedom.
Jewish Law, Loyalty to the Land, and Historical Ties
Jewish tradition also teaches respect for the government and the laws of the land. The Talmud contains the principle known as “Dina d’malchuta dina,” meaning “the law of the kingdom is the law.” This concept encourages Jews to obey the legitimate civil laws of the country in which they live, as long as those laws do not require them to violate Jewish law. Orthodox Jews therefore often see themselves as both faithful Jews and loyal citizens. Noting the Fourth of July can be understood as recognizing the blessings of living in a country that protects the rights of its citizens while allowing religious communities to maintain their identities.
The relationship between Judaism and American democracy was also reflected in an important historical event. In 1790, President George Washington wrote a famous letter to the Hebrew Congregation in Newport, Rhode Island. In his letter, he promised that the new nation would give “to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance.” These words became a symbol of America’s commitment to religious tolerance and equality. Many Jewish leaders have regarded this message as evidence that the values of the United States align with the Jewish belief that every human being deserves dignity and respect.
At the same time, Orthodox Jews recognize that patriotism should not replace religious devotion. Judaism teaches that ultimate loyalty belongs to the Torah and its commandments. Love for one’s country is important, but it should not become a form of worship. Orthodox Jewish thinkers often encourage a balanced approach: appreciating the freedoms and opportunities offered by the United States while maintaining a strong commitment to Jewish faith and practice. This perspective allows Orthodox Jews to participate in civic life without compromising their religious identity.
Responsibilities of Freedom and Tikkun Olam
The Fourth of July can also inspire reflection on the responsibilities that accompany freedom. American citizens are encouraged to vote, serve their communities, and contribute to the common good. Orthodox Judaism of course teaches that every individual has an obligation to help others through acts of kindness, charity, and justice. The Hebrew concept of “tikkun olam,” often translated as “repairing the world,” encourages people to improve general society through being an example of ethical behaviour and compassion. Jews should behave in a manner that the non-Jews recognise as being correct. By participating in charitable work and community service, Orthodox Jews can express both their religious values and their appreciation for the opportunities provided by American society. We are absolutely different but we still embody the values that today’s world has inherited from Abrahamic religions.
Conclusion: Fourth of July Reflections for Orthodox Jews
In conclusion, although the Fourth of July is an American civic holiday, it reflects many important themes embodied within Orthodox Judaism. It is impossible to hide the immorality and amorality of the behaviour of the majority of secular Americans. Unfortunately almost every secular society that has existed is saturated with this. However this is not the fault of or a result of the values of the idealists. They could not dictate to the masses, merely emphasize the value of freedom, the importance of responsibility, and the need for gratitude.
For Orthodox Jews in the United States, Independence Day can serve as an occasion to note the blessings of religious freedom and to appreciate a country that has allowed Jewish life to thrive. Orthodox Jews can celebrate the underlying ideals of America that still allow them to be deeply connected to the timeless teachings of Judaism.
As to the future …
Leave a Reply